Skip to main content

Our Listings
Explore Areas
Sell
Buy
About Us

Menu

Home
Buyers
Sellers
Featured Areas
Property Search
Success Stories
Helpful Guides
Accessibility
Contact

Company

Home
Success Stories
Blog
Accessibility
Contact

Real Estate

Buyers
Sellers
Featured Areas
Helpful Guides

Tools

Perfect Home Finder
What’s My Home Worth?
Mortgage Calculator

Address

[email protected]
574-583-3171
209 N Main St
Monticello 47960 Indiana

Lake Shafer

Lake Shafer is a picturesque lake nestled in Monticello, Indiana, renowned for its natural beauty and recreational offerings. Spanning approximately 1,291 acres, it is part of the Twin Lakes region, alongside Lake Freeman. This man-made lake was created in the 1920s as a result of damming the Tippecanoe River, and it has since become a popular destination for tourists and locals alike.

Lake Shafer is a haven for water enthusiasts, offering activities such as boating, water skiing, fishing, and swimming. Its serene waters are dotted with marinas and waterfront properties, making it a hub for lakefront living and leisure. The shoreline features Indiana Beach amusement park, campgrounds, and resorts, providing ample opportunities for relaxation and outdoor adventures.

Known for its vibrant atmosphere, Lake Shafer hosts various events and festivals throughout the year, attracting visitors from all around. Whether it's a day of sunbathing, a thrilling jet ski ride, or a peaceful evening cruise, Lake Shafer offers diverse experiences to suit every preference. Its scenic charm and recreational amenities make it a cherished gem in the heart of Monticello, drawing people to its shores year after year.

Recommended For You

Let us know what you're looking for, and we'll let you know what we find

* First Name:

* Last Name:

* Email:

Phone:

Prefer to have someone call? Just let us know

Email preference Phone call

Want to see about scheduling a showing?

Pick a date (preferrably in the future)

/

Message:

Location

Price

Beds

Baths

+ Additional Filters/Criteria

Home Size

Lot Size sqft use acres

Year Built

Days Listed

Property Status

Active

Pending

Sold

Property Types

Select All

Commercial

Condo/Townhouse/Co-Op

Farms/Ranch

Lot/Land/Acreage

Mobile/Manufactured

Multi Family

Rental Properties

Residential Income

Single Family

Vacation/Time-Share

Property Features

Adult Community

Air Conditioning

Barn/Equestrian

Basement

Fireplace

Garage

Pool

Primary on Main

View

Waterfront

homes from to

Hide Map

List View
Grid View

Sorted by

1 - 23 of 23 | Previous Page 1 of 1 Next

$289,000
23

5683 E Bass Center Road, Monticello, IN

5683 E Bass Center Road
Monticello, IN
2 Beds

1 Bath

840 Home (sqft)

1 Bath

5,899 Lot (sqft)
$394,900
36

3342 N Shore Acres Court, Monticello, IN

3342 N Shore Acres Court
Monticello, IN
2 Beds

1 Bath

840 Home (sqft)

1 Bath

83 Lot (sqft)
$1,150,000
36

2636 N Peterson Drive, Monticello, IN

2636 N Peterson Drive
Monticello, IN
7 Beds

6.5 Baths

4,507 Home (sqft)

6.5 Baths

43,560 Lot (sqft)
$625,000
36

5100 E Quiet Water Court, Monticello, IN

5100 E Quiet Water Court
Monticello, IN
4 Beds

2.5 Baths

2,304 Home (sqft)

2.5 Baths

14,985 Lot (sqft)
$375,000
34

3776 N Doug Court, Monticello, IN

3776 N Doug Court
Monticello, IN
2 Beds

1 Bath

1,008 Home (sqft)

1 Bath

8,843 Lot (sqft)
$599,900
36

4703 E Elmer Girtz Drive, Monticello, IN

4703 E Elmer Girtz Drive
Monticello, IN
4 Beds

2.5 Baths

2,400 Home (sqft)

2.5 Baths

6,099 Lot (sqft)
$445,000
11

5271 E Willow Court, Monticello, IN

5271 E Willow Court
Monticello, IN
4 Beds

2.5 Baths

2,016 Home (sqft)

2.5 Baths

16,989 Lot (sqft)
$755,000
33

5259 E Willow Court, Monticello, IN

5259 E Willow Court
Monticello, IN
5 Beds

3 Baths

4,724 Home (sqft)

3 Baths

19,167 Lot (sqft)
$529,900
36

3480 E Bailey Road, Monticello, IN

3480 E Bailey Road
Monticello, IN
3 Beds

2 Baths

2,300 Home (sqft)

2 Baths

9,584 Lot (sqft)
$319,900
18

3097 E Stahl Road, Monon, IN

3097 E Stahl Road
Monon, IN
2 Beds

1 Bath

1,102 Home (sqft)

1 Bath

12,633 Lot (sqft)
$475,000
36

3291 E Stahl Road, Monticello, IN

3291 E Stahl Road
Monticello, IN
3 Beds

2 Baths

1,839 Home (sqft)

2 Baths

6,534 Lot (sqft)
$599,500
36

5384 E Quiet Water Ct Court, Monticello, IN

5384 E Quiet Water Ct Court
Monticello, IN
5 Beds

3.5 Baths

3,322 Home (sqft)

3.5 Baths

11,762 Lot (sqft)
$294,900
23

5629 N Stahl Road, Monon, IN

5629 N Stahl Road
Monon, IN
2 Beds

1.5 Baths

1,092 Home (sqft)

1.5 Baths

12,633 Lot (sqft)
$625,999
35

2308 N Sullivan Court, Monticello, IN

2308 N Sullivan Court
Monticello, IN
3 Beds

3 Baths

3,284 Home (sqft)

3 Baths

7,406 Lot (sqft)
$797,500
30

4033 N Denver Court, Monticello, IN

4033 N Denver Court
Monticello, IN
3 Beds

3 Baths

2,707 Home (sqft)

3 Baths

10,455 Lot (sqft)
$450,000
27

5008 E Shady Point Drive, Monticello, IN

5008 E Shady Point Drive
Monticello, IN
3 Beds

2 Baths

1,765 Home (sqft)

2 Baths

31,886 Lot (sqft)
$410,000
17

6105 N 300 E, Monon, IN

6105 N 300 E
Monon, IN
3 Beds

2 Baths

1,300 Home (sqft)

2 Baths

6,099 Lot (sqft)
$870,000
36

3743 N West Shafer Drive, Monticello, IN

3743 N West Shafer Drive
Monticello, IN
3 Beds

2 Baths

1,860 Home (sqft)

2 Baths

1.05 Lot (ac)
$450,000
30

3078 E BOLLER Court, Monticello, IN

3078 E BOLLER Court
Monticello, IN
2 Beds

1.5 Baths

1,344 Home (sqft)

1.5 Baths

24,394 Lot (sqft)
$499,900
36

4372 N Shorewood Court, Monticello, IN

4372 N Shorewood Court
Monticello, IN
2 Beds

2 Baths

1,188 Home (sqft)

2 Baths

23,958 Lot (sqft)
$1,175,000
35

4954 E Bayfront Court, Monticello, IN

4954 E Bayfront Court
Monticello, IN
5 Beds

4 Baths

4,378 Home (sqft)

4 Baths

26,572 Lot (sqft)
$374,500
36

5220 E Wenz Drive, Monticello, IN

5220 E Wenz Drive
Monticello, IN
2 Beds

2.5 Baths

960 Home (sqft)

2.5 Baths

8,974 Lot (sqft)
$225,000
22

5063 NW Shafer Drive, Monticello, IN

5063 NW Shafer Drive
Monticello, IN
2 Beds

0.5 Bath

368 Home (sqft)

0.5 Bath

12,415 Lot (sqft)

Previous Page 1 of 1 Next

The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data exchange (“IDX”) program of the Indiana Regional MLS®. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use, that it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS.
Copyright© 2026 IRMLS. All rights reserved.
Last Updated On: 3/4/26 7:47 AM PST
Walk Score provided by walkscore.com

This IDX Solution is (c) Diverse Solutions 2026. Privacy | Terms & Conditions

Save favorite listings, searches, and get the latest alerts

Remember me

or

Sign in to, or create an account using your existing social account:

Forgot password?

Create an Account

Fill in your email, and we'll send you a message with instructions on how to reset your password. Please make sure to use the same email address you provided during registration. Email:

close Back to Login

New Password: Confirm Password:

close

Save your favorite listings, searches, and receive the latest listing alerts

First Name: Last Name: Email: Please confirm if you want to receive e-mail updates from and other Diverse Solutions products: I confirm, I would like to receive e-mail updates I do not want to receive e-mail updates Phone Number: Password: Confirm Password: Remember me

or

Sign in to, or create an account using your existing social account:

Already have an account? Login

Share My QR

Success!

574-583-3171
[email protected]

About

Home
Success Stories
Blog
Accessibility
Contact

Real Estate

Buyers
Sellers
Featured Areas
Helpful Guides

Tools

Perfect Home Finder
What’s My Home Worth?
Mortgage Calculator

© 2026. John Sells Homes. All rights reserved.
Sitemap. Privacy Policy.

Made with by AgentFire